Podcast

Thursday, November 10, 2022

The Expanded Ultimate Story Checklist!

I’m expanding The Ultimate Story Checklist!  

The Checklist came to be when I took all the advice I’d offered up to that point on the blog and rephrased the posts as a series of questions you could ask about your manuscript.  Each question linked back to the original post that inspired it.  Then I later rewrote everything when I turned it into my book, The Secrets of Story.

Later, I kept studying examples and came up with various posts called Rulebook Casefile that backed up my points, and various posts called Straying from the Party Line that seemed to contradict them.  

For the expansion, I’m redoing every entry to use the text from the book, tacking on any Casefiles or SftPLs afterwards, and including a chart of how 30 movies answered that question.  

This expansion is ongoing.  So far, I’ve only done the first three Parts and the rest still link back to the original posts that inspired them.  

If you still want to read the original posts (and the original comments), I’ll leave that version up, too, underneath this one.  

I’ve used this list to evaluate my favorite stories and my own work. The result: my favorite stories all pass and my own work always fall short. This tells me what I’m doing wrong.

The goal is simple: Try to answer yes as often as possible. Of course, every story is unique and no story that I’ve evaluated has answered yes to all 122 questions, nor should it. Check out the Checklist Roadtests over there in the sidebar, to see how lots of great movies did. If you want to try it yourself, a downloadable version of this list as a word document is available here (link fixed!)

(This list is primarily for stand-alone stories such as
screenplays, novels and plays, but don’t worry, theres a separate “pilot” checklist for the first episode of continuing stories such as TV series, book series, web series, and comics)

PART 1: CONCEPT

The Pitch: Does this concept excite everyone who hears about it?

Story Fundamentals: Will this concept generate a strong story?
 Does this challenge represent the hero’s greatest hope and/or greatest fear and/or an ironic answer to the hero’s question?

The Hook: Will this be marketable and generate word of mouth?
 Does the story satisfy the basic human urges that get people to buy and recommend this genre? 

PART 2: CHARACTER

Believe: Do we recognize the hero as a human being?

Care: Do we feel for the hero?

Invest: Can we trust the hero to tackle this challenge?

PART 3: STRUCTURE (assuming that the story is about the solving of a large problem)

1st Quarter: Is the challenge laid out in the first quarter?

2nd Quarter: Does the hero try the easy way in the second quarter?

3rd Quarter: Does the hero try the hard way in the third quarter?

4th Quarter: Does the challenge climax in the fourth quarter?

PART 4: SCENEWORK

The Set-Up: Does this scene begin with the essential elements it needs?

The Conflict: Is this a compelling collision of competing agendas?  

The Outcome: Does this scene change the story going forward?

PART 5: DIALOGUE

Empathetic: Is the dialogue true to human nature?

Specific: Is the dialogue specific to this world and each personality?

Heightened: Is the dialogue more pointed and dynamic than real talk?

Strategic: Are certain dialogue scenes withheld until necessary?

PART 6: TONE

Genre: Does the story tap into pre-established expectations?

Framing: Does the story set, reset, upset and ultimately exceed its own expectations?
 Is there a dramatic question posed early on, which will establish in the audience’s mind which moment will mark the end of the story? 

PART 7: THEME

Difficult: Is the meaning of the story derived from a fundamental moral dilemma?

Grounded: Do the stakes ring true to the world of the audience?

Subtle: Is the theme interwoven throughout so that it need not be discussed often?

Untidy: Is the dilemma ultimately irresolvable?

Whew! So how did your story do? Go check out the Checklist Roadtests to see how some great stories line up.

Wednesday, November 09, 2022

The Expanded Ultimate Story Checklist: Is there an epilogue/aftermath/denouement in which the challenge is finally resolved (or succumbed to), and we see how much the hero has changed?

Real life is mostly epilogue. The ramifications of our crises linger for years, and we’re never sure if it turned out right. In fiction, we want tidier concluding moments, although not too tidy. 
  • In exciting stories like Speed, this is often the moment when the hero and heroine take a breather and confirm that they really do care about each other, which often results in a first kiss. 
  • The surviving heroes of The Great Escape get dragged back to prison, content in the knowledge that they’ve caused a huge distraction. 
  • Many comedies, like Date Night, wrap up the dilemma (the marriage problems, in this instance) in a quiet scene just after the climax, which is fine. 
  • In movies like Rear Window, we see that the underlying dilemma (the different interests of Kelly and Stewart) has not been resolved at all, though the climax brought about a temporary truce. This can work, too.
Rulebook Casefile: Reversible Behavior
An interesting thing I noticed when re-watching Ghostbusters was how muted and subtle the character arc was.  Our hero, Bill Murray, never has a midpoint disaster or a spiritual crisis. He never seems to doubt himself or get humbled.  He seems like the same cocky rogue all the way through…or is he?

He does in fact change quite a bit, and it’s set up very nicely through reversible behavior.  In the very first scene, Murray’s paranormal researcher is sabotaging his own ESP experiment just so that he can hit on the test subject.  He doesn’t truly believe in or care about the supernatural, he’s just using it to get dates.  
This scene is neatly reversed two thirds of the way in, when the new object of Murray’s affections, who has so far resisted his advances, throws herself at him.  He’s very tempted, but instead he forces himself to admit that she’s possessed, and he now values solving her problem more than scoring with her.  It’s not played like a big moment, nor should it be.  By subtly contrasting this scene with the first, the movie allows us to notice the difference for ourselves, whether consciously or subconsciously. 

The 40 Year Old Virgin

YES, he consummates at his wedding.  There’s even a nice moment where he kicks a floor waxer out of their suite, showing his newfound assertiveness.

Alien

YES, she gives a matter-of-fact unapologetic account of blowing up the ship, then goes to sleep with the cat.

An Education

YES. She’s happy at Oxford, with a new boy, pretending that she’s never been to Paris.

The Babadook

YES. It’s half-resolved/half-succumbed-to.  It’s interesting that some behaviors are reversed (She talks about her husband and let’s others do so) but some aren’t, (the basement is still verboten, he son is still violent)

Blazing Saddles

YES. He gives a speech then rides off into the sunset with the Waco Kid. 

Blue Velvet

YES. he’s embraced his parent’s idyllic life and possibly married Sandy, but we see the Robin eating the beetle and we have to wonder if he’s crushed or absorbed the evil, which are two different ways of reading that image. 

The Bourne Identity

YES. he tells her that he has no ID and smiles.  

Bridesmaids

YES. She enjoys the wedding, bonds with Lillian, accepts the cop’s love.

Casablanca

YES. this time he stands up to the Nazis, then he goes off to join a Free French garrison in Braziville with Louis.

Chinatown

YES. There’s just a brief moment after the finale, when he’s told “Forget it, Jake, it’s Chinatown.”  

Donnie Brasco

YES.  His family accepts him but he’s disgusted by his medal.

Do the Right Thing

YES. He talks to Sal the next morning.

The Farewell

YES. She returns home to New York, feels overwhelmed, then stops on the street and shouts “Ha!”, which she refused to do before.  We then find out that the grandma is still alive six years later.

The Fighter

YES. Interview, Dicky says, “He put Lowell back on the map.” Micky says “We”.  “Who’s the pride of Lowell now? Right here.” Points at Micky. “I gotta go.”

Frozen

YES. She’s happy in love, able to live outside the castle, and reconciled with her sister.

The Fugitive

YES. Kimble saves Gerard this time. Gerard also has reversible behavior: “Don’t tell anybody.”

Get Out

YES. He rediscovers peace-making and chooses not to choke Rose to death (but Peele points out that he ultimately leaves her to die alone in the road like his mother died).  Rod delivers the moral: “I told you not to go in that house.”  Chris presumably agrees. 

Groundhog Day

YES. Succumbed to happily: he says “Let’s live here.”

How to Train Your Dragon

YES. He is accepted by the village and is physically transformed.

In a Lonely Place

YES. he watches her walk away and declares himself dead inside.

Iron Man

YES. He tries again with Pepper, but fails, and then tells the world who he is. 

Lady Bird

YES. She goes to church and then calls her mom and leaves a message admitting that she loves Sacramento and her mom. 

Raising Arizona

YES. They send gifts to Nathan Jr. as he grows up.  Maybe they’re able to have kids, or maybe that’s just a dream.

Rushmore

YES. he introduces his real father to everyone, and his selection of song “I wish that I knew what I know now, when I was younger,” lets us know that he’s learned.

Selma

YES. Johnson certainly shows how much he’s changed with his “We shall overcome” speech.  Has King changed?  He’s certainly wearier and bruised, and feeling more guilty about the deaths.   We see onscreen graphics telling us what happened to everybody.  

The Shining

NO. an ambiguous final scene was cut out, leaving us with a quick cut to black as soon as they get away.  

Sideways

YES. He drives north and knocks on her door. There’s no reversible behavior…they could have ended with him drinking merlot to show he’s changed, but that would have been too on the nose (no pun intended.)

The Silence of the Lambs

YES. She says lambs stopped screaming.

Star Wars

YES. He’s now a celebrated hero.

Sunset Boulevard

YES. Earlier in the climax, when he finally has the strength to resist Norma, even when she threatens suicide.  

Tuesday, November 08, 2022

The Expanded Ultimate Story Checklist: Does the hero’s inner struggle climax shortly after (or possibly at the same time as) her outer struggle?

Catharsis only comes about because of crisis. We put off personal change until the last possible moment, at the crux of the crisis or afterward.

The inner conflict should not end too early. Once when a producer was quickly summing up the problems he had with my script, we got to the third act and he said, “It’s very exciting, but after a certain point it all runs downhill.” I asked him to explain, but he couldn’t, since he considered the point self-evident. I thought he was crazy. Was he saying I didn’t have enough conflict? There’s no way: It was an over-the-top, one-man-against-an-army-of-crazies finale. How does that roll downhill?

I think that now, years later, I’ve finally figured out what he was saying. My hero hadn't run out of exterior conflict; my hero had run out of dilemma. He still had a lot of bad guys to be defeated, but he no longer had internal tension caused by those actions.

Once I figured this out, it was an easy fix: I had to send my good guy into the final confrontation still seeking the temptation the bad guy had offered. I had to push the good guy’s final rejection of that temptation as late as possible, right at the heart of the climax. The hero’s dilemma should be exacerbated by the conflict, and vice versa, until the last moment, when the resolution of the dilemma and the resolution of the conflict should happen at about the same time.
  • In any movie where it might be all in the hero’s head, the inner struggle and outer struggle automatically end at the same time, such as in The Babadook and Groundhog Day. 
  • The hero of How to Train Your Dragon reconciles with his father during the heat of battle. 
  • Die Hard is very tidy: Willis wins his wife back by shooting the bad guy dead. 
Note: Sometimes the inner struggle happens early in sports movies. In both Breaking Away and The Fighter, the emotional breakthroughs happen before the hero competes at the end. The real story is over, and the final triumph is essentially a victory lap.
Every hero must complete both an outer journey and an inner journey. These journeys should overlap at certain points, but not the whole time. Sometimes you can create a finale where the hero completes both journeys at the same moment (such as using the force to blow up the Death Star in Star Wars) but not always. Often, the hero must complete them at different times, but it’s good to have the culminations of these journeys both happen near the climax. Sometimes the hero completing the inner journey allows them to compete the outer journey right afterwards. Sometimes completing the outer journey allows them to complete the inner journey in the epilogue.

On first viewing of Get Out, the viewer is not super aware of Chris’s inner journey, though we can tell it’s there: He’s trying to forgive himself for doing nothing when he mother was dying in the street from an accident. We see Missy elicit this information from him while hypnotizing him, and we see him admit his feeling of guilt to Rose later, but then, since the outer journey is so exciting, we don’t really think about the inner journey very much.

But Peele is doing a lot of subtle work to make sure we feel Chris’s inner journey on a subconscious level, even if we don’t think about it. Only when you listen to the DVD commentary is all this work made explicit.

We can’t know this on first viewing, but Chris’s inner journey begins when he hits a deer on the way to see Rose’s parents. He insists on getting out to see if the deer is alright, but finds it dead. He then insists on calling the police, despite the fact that doing so often ends poorly for black men. To Chris, the deer is his mom, and he’s still trying to save her.

Later, when Chris has his bizarre encounter with Georgina, and sees her cry, he suspects that she may be a victim in some way, which also makes him think of his mom.

Later, when Chris is held captive in the basement, there’s a huge buck head on the wall. According to Peele, this represents Chris’s dad. It shouldn’t have been up to Chris to make sure his mom was okay, it should have been up to his dad, who “wasn’t in the picture.” Chris escapes and kills Rose’s dad by stabbing him with the points of the buck’s head. He is not only displacing Rose’s father as the dominant male in the house, he’s replacing his own dad. His mom is the deer and he is the rescuing buck his dad couldn’t be. As Peele says:
  • The buck is of course not only a used not only to describe strong black men in the past, but is a symbol, the male version of the doe that he hits.
But Chris still needs to take one more step to resolve his inner journey. When he’s driving away from the house, Georgina, controlled by the grandmother’s mind, runs out to stop him but he accidentally hits her with his car. He then starts to drive away, leaving her limp body in the road behind him. Then he stops. He can’t leave her, even though he knows that the real Georgina is buried deep inside her and may never be able to be rescued. He just can’t leave a black woman dying in the street like his mom died. So he goes back, gets her unconscious body, and puts it in his driver’s seat.

In the end, it doesn’t work. She wakes up, still controlled by the grandma, tries to take over the car, crashes it, and presumably dies in the crash. But still Chris tried, and trying finally allowed him to forgive himself for not trying to save his own mother. As Peele says:
  • When he went back for Georgina, he made the only decision that would free his soul.
What’s the point of including an inner journey so subtle that you have to watch the commentary to spot it? The hope is that, even if the audience doesn’t see it, they can feel it. We sense that there’s an elemental power in Chris’s use of the buck head. We sense that something deep is going on inside when he tries to rescue Georgina, even if we’re too caught up in it to think of his mom. “Know More Than You Show” doesn’t just apply to plot, it also applies to theme.

The 40 Year Old Virgin

YES, he flies through the billboard and admits the titular problem at the last possible minute.

Alien

YES. Pretty much.  She has no time to process her decision to break from the company until after she kills the thing.

An Education

YES. It is only after she’s been at Oxford for a while that forgives herself and put the affair in the proper context.

The Babadook

YES. The same moment. 

Blazing Saddles

YES. Afterwards, he realizes that he’s got to go ride the west saving others.

Blue Velvet

YES. he comes shooting out of the closet.

The Bourne Identity

YES. he finally figures out who he really is as he confronts the bad guy.  

Bridesmaids

YES.

Casablanca

YES. Shortly before, but it’s okay that the final confrontation with Strasser “rolls downhill”.

Chinatown

YES. The same moment. 

Donnie Brasco

YES.  basically, it never really ends.  He’s still conflicted, even though it’s over. 

Do the Right Thing

YES. The same time.

The Farewell

YES. She finally tells her Nai Nai one piece of truth, that she didn’t get the fellowship.  They bond as much as they can without the truth of the diagnosis coming out.

The Fighter

NO. Quite a bit before.  The last 15 minutes of this movie “roll downhill” a little bit, as Mickey solves his problems out of the ring well before the last fight. 

Frozen

YES. At the same time.

The Fugitive

YES. to the degree that he has an inner struggle.  He finally trusts that Gerard trusts him, and his inner journey comes full circle. 

Get Out

YES. Chris chooses to try to save Georgina and thus makes his peace with his mom’s death.  He fails to save her, but “saves” Walter just in time for Walter to kill Rose and himself. 

Groundhog Day

YES. The same time. 

How to Train Your Dragon

YES. He reconciles with his father in the middle of the final battle. 

In a Lonely Place

YES. after he is cleared, the real internal crisis comes.

Iron Man

YES. Afterwards, when he finally decides who he is. 

Lady Bird

YES. She accepts her name, but then lies about where she’s from at a college party, then drinks herself into oblivion and wakes up at the hospital. 

Raising Arizona

YES. after Smalls is dead, they hash out their relationship issues with Nathan Arizona.

Rushmore

NO. it ends earlier, and it ends offscreen.  They want us to believe that he’s buidling up to a school shooting, so they don’t show us that he’s dealt everything and moved on.  We just figure that out when we see the play.

Selma

YES. The victory seems to assure King that he made the right decision in turning back.

The Shining

YES. It never climaxes.  He’s still freaked out at the end.  

Sideways

YES. After. 

The Silence of the Lambs

YES. Symbolically: girl who’s about to be skinned stops screaming. 

Star Wars

YES. He resolves his inner struggle at the final moment in order to succeed.

Sunset Boulevard

Well, shortly before. He finally finds his self-respect, then gets killed.