What the Nominees Were: Black Panther, BlacKKKlansman, Bohemian Rhapsody, The Favourite, Green Book, Roma, A Star is Born, Vice
Other Movies That Should Have Been Considered: A Quiet Place was pretty great.
What Did Win: Green Book
How It’s Aged: This is one of the most universally-despised winners, but really, it’s fine. Yes, its take on race relations was already a little creaky in 2018, but I’m convinced that its heart was in the right place, and I think Viggo Mortensen and Mahershala Ali do a great job.
How It’s Aged: This is one of the most universally-despised winners, but really, it’s fine. Yes, its take on race relations was already a little creaky in 2018, but I’m convinced that its heart was in the right place, and I think Viggo Mortensen and Mahershala Ali do a great job.
What Should’ve Won: The Favourite
How Hard Was the Decision: Hard, because there were no overwhelming contenders this year. If only I could borrow Get Out and move it to this year! Ultimately I had to decide between this and Black Panther, which would have been an equally worthy winner, but this one felt more like a Best Picture.
Director: Yorgos Lanthimos
Writers: Deborah Davis and Tony McNamara
Stars: Olivia Colman, Emma Stone, Rachel Weisz
How Hard Was the Decision: Hard, because there were no overwhelming contenders this year. If only I could borrow Get Out and move it to this year! Ultimately I had to decide between this and Black Panther, which would have been an equally worthy winner, but this one felt more like a Best Picture.
Director: Yorgos Lanthimos
Writers: Deborah Davis and Tony McNamara
Stars: Olivia Colman, Emma Stone, Rachel Weisz
The Story: In 1708, Queen Anne of England shows little interest in making war on France and instead focuses on her lesbian affair with Sarah Churchill (ancestor of Winston.) Sarah’s poor relation Abigail Hill arrives, looking for help, but soon proves to be a self-serving schemer, replacing Sarah in Anne’s bed.
Any Nominations or Wins: Colman won Actress, but it lost everything else: Picture, Director, Supporting Actress for both Stone and Weisz, Original Screenplay, Cinematography, Costume Design, Editing and Production Design.
Why It Didn’t Win: This is an odd movie and an unpleasant one is some ways, so it couldn’t compete with feel-good material like Green Book.
Why It Didn’t Win: This is an odd movie and an unpleasant one is some ways, so it couldn’t compete with feel-good material like Green Book.
Why It Should Have Won:
- I had followed Olivia Colman from her early days as a bit player on the cult sketch show “That Mitchell and Webb Look,” where she frequently stood out for her hilariously deadpan line readings (“Couldn’t do enough for you”) and was tremendously gratified to see her finally become a big star and Oscar winner here, giving a startlingly raw performance as a black hole of neediness.
- Lanthimos is a director with a very unique point of view in every way, from the typography of the on-screen titles, to the jarring sound design, to the innovative use of wide-angle lenses. I like his candlelit scenes more than Kubrick’s in Barry Lyndon (maybe just the result of 40 years of improvement in film stock.) He’s a visionary in the best sense of the word.
- Emma Stone had just won an Oscar for her deeply sympathetic performance as Mia in La La Land, but now she was ready to tell the world that that sort of universally appealing character wasn’t really what she wanted to do forever. This began a series of darker and/or odder roles, with and without Lanthimos, that showed a much flintier resolve than she had earlier shown. As it turns out, she excels at everything.
- The life of a screenwriter is hard. Deborah Davis wrote the original script as a spec in 1998, and everybody loved it, but then she had to spend a full 20 years getting it made. Even for a script as beautifully-directed and well-received as this one, is that amount of time worth it? I’m glad she stuck with it, because we got a great movie out of it, but it’s too much to ask of anyone.
- The movie makes the daring choice to begin us firmly on Abigail’s side (she is, after all, played by Emma Stone) and then hang us out to dry when we suddenly realize halfway through that we’ve picked the wrong horse, and Sarah was actually the better lover. As Sarah belatedly tries to explain to the queen (and us), “You wish me to lie to you? ‘Oh you look like an angel fallen from heaven, your majesty.’ No. Sometimes, you look like a badger. And you can rely on me to tell you. […] I will not lie! That is love!” We share with the queen the shocking realization that this is true.























































