Oedipus is a baby in a basket. So is Achilles. So is Superman. One variation on the theme is Moses, who is sent to less modest circumstances, but even there, he’s separated from the source of his future super-powers until he discovers his birth parents.
And of course Harry Potter is a classic “baby in a basket” hero.
Why does this archetype work so well? Because there are two competing human impulses: the inclination to admire those of great birth, and the contradictory inclination to admire those who learned from rough circumstances. The magic of the “baby in a basket” is that he gets to be both at the same time, ensuring that everyone will like him
These stories also speak to us because they reflect our universal sense of being misunderstood. We all feel like we are destined for greatness and mistreated by a world that insists on treating us like ordinary people, and we long to read about characters for whom that’s really true. The moment where the hero finds out that he was born to be great is the ultimate wish fulfillment for the reader.
Rowling also taps into another universal feeling, as least for anybody with a sibling. Every sibling feels, at one time or another, that they’re being slighted in favor of another sibling. Rowling takes that universal sense of injustice and magnifies it a thousand-fold, creating deep identification.
58 comments:
1122
Cryptic
Your point is valid and helpful, but isn't there a way to express it that isn't so depressing and cynical? Basically, you're saying it's our worst impulses that cause us to like this trope.
"We all feel like we are destined for greatness and mistreated by a world that insists on treating us like ordinary people" -- do we *all* feel like that? Is that actually true for anybody other than narcissists and sociopaths?
Same with the point about the sibling. It seems that the basic idea behind a lot of your points like this is that "We all have these deluded selfish impulses. Deep inside, we're all shitty narcissists. But through literature, we can indulge these narcissistic fantasies through imaginary wish-fulfillment."
If that's what reading is, how is reading not just another vice? If that's what it takes to be a good storyteller, why would anyone want to be a storyteller -- just taking the audience's worst impulses and repackaging them in a way such that the audience can indulge those impulses without consequence?
Sounds like joyless, ignoble work to me. If that's what I thought being a storyteller really was, I wouldn't want to do it.
By the way, I hung out with Jac Jemc last night (you met her at that literary salon at the Hopleaf, around the time you moved to Chicago) and she says she uses SECRETS OF STORY in the creative writing class she teaches at (I think) Northeastern Illinois University, and that the students respond really positively to it.
1122
The world is a sewer, James. The most fascinating story to come out this week: https://deadspin.com/teen-girl-posed-for-8-years-as-married-man-to-write-abo-1820305588
As for Jac, we're Facebook friends we have a mutual appreciation society because we both liked each other's books (for those that don't know, she wrote an acclaimed haunted house novel called "The Grip of It"). You should have invited me along!
1122
Your point is valid and helpful, but isn't there a way to express it that isn't so depressing and cynical? Basically, you're saying it's our worst impulses that cause us to like this trope.
Yeah, which is why you don't see the "baby in a basket" trope in most fiction. It's powerful but it's also pandering.
"We all feel like we are destined for greatness and mistreated by a world that insists on treating us like ordinary people" -- do we *all* feel like that? Is that actually true for anybody other than narcissists and sociopaths?
The feeling that one is unappreciated and mistreated is a human universal. Because it's true -- everyone is. Such is life, yo. What matters is how you deal with that sentiment. What adds to the feeling's power as an element of fiction is that it's a feeling that society, for obvious and very good reasons, does not encourage us to talk about. Stories that address deep feelings within us that we haven't or can't fully grapple with are stories that resonate.
Take a famous modern example: Rocky Balboa. People love him not just because he's an underdog facing terrible odds. It’s not just that everyone dumps on him, though that’s also true. (Everyone gives him grief except Adrian, which is part of why we root for them to get together.) No, we love him because throughout it all, Rocky keeps being a good person. Which is how most everyone understands themselves but we don't want to admit. Everyone feels that they’re hard done by, and everyone feels like they try to be good regardless, and everyone feels like nobody notices. We want to be recognized for our virtue in the face of difficulty, our everyday heroism. We want to be seen as “not just another bum from the neighborhood.” Even if we know it's not true. Maybe especially if we know it's not true.
The genius of Rocky is that this sentiment is indulged but not quite too far. He finds a woman who loves him, he finds self-respect and recognition, and, crucially, he doesn’t Win It All. He lost, which kept the wish fulfillment aspect from choking the story. Yet he still won the fight in the way that we knew mattered to him: he went the distance.
Writing stories that mess with our less noble sentiments can get icky. You have to recognize what you're dealing with. You can no doubt think of three dozen stories that leave you feeling a little dirty by how totally they pandered to the audience's sense of aggrieved entitlement. The deeper, usually unspoken feelings we have are powerful stuff, not to be used without consideration.
Well, you can use them willy-nilly, but the results will probably be kind of disgusting.
1123
I like your take, Harvey. It splits the difference between Matt's perhaps-justified-but-paralyzingly-depressing cynicism, and my instinct that stories should address something higher than our worst instincts. The ROCKY example was perfect.
But nothing could be more uplifting and idealistic than Harry Potter (and I'd argue that Rocky panders to our worst instincts in other ways.) I may describe things in ultracynical ways but that doesn't mean that Rowling was writing from a cynical place (One could argue that writing about a boy using a gender-neutral version of her name was a cynical decision, though.) There's nothing wrong or cynical about gratifying universal feelings of aggrievement. You're making people feel good, as well you should.
I'm not the one who wrote a well-regarded book of advice, so I know this is presumptuous, but I think that if you push yourself to find non-cynical ways to describe these (valid and useful!) insights, you might discover new truths and your advice might be more palatable. For instance, Tolkien's "On Fairy Stories" and C.S. Lewis' "Experiment in Criticism" describe why certain stories work and others don't, and interrogate the different ways people read and what they bring to that reading, but it never feels cynical. I'm not energized to write when I'm coming from a cynical place that looks down on the reader.
And I don't mean to say Rowling was writing from a cynical place. But the way you describe her writing, you make it sound as if she does.
this is such a good article. opening a different perspective to so much about the book or the ideology basically. i really like the amount of effort put into it. keep writing more
Are you curious about the major sites of Kazanosite and Baccarat Site? The most comfortable and safe place to play online casinos is not recommended on any verification site. 온라인카지노
We recommend the Toto Site Safe Park. The nickname "major toto site" is not a name that can be applied anywhere. It reflects the high praise of users for its sincere operation. I'm showing you the true value. 안전놀이터
Comedian 온라인바카라 has admitted that he is living with the new love in his life, whom he started dating after his divorce about five years ago.
The prolific chat show host made the revelation on his YouTube channel on Wednesday.
"There's a restaurant selling 카지노보증사이트 meals that I frequent, but I've stopped going there," he said. "The reason is that my girlfriend is at home with me. She cooks 슬롯게임추천 t for me, so I'm being well fed. The auntie who owns the restaurant treats me like family and I told her I won't be coming here as often as I used to."
Your post is very helpful and information is reliable. I am satisfied with your post. Thank you so much for sharing this wonderful post. If you have any assignment requirement then you are at the right place. 스포츠토토사이트
I always think about what is. It seems to be a perfect article that seems to blow away such worries. 안전메이저놀이터 seems to be the best way to show something. When you have time, please write an article about what means!!
I’d like to thank you for the efforts you’ve put in writing this blog. I’m hoping to view the same high-grade blog posts by you in the future as well. In truth, your creative writing abilities has inspired me to get my own blog now. 먹튀검증전문
That's a really impressive new idea! 안전한놀이터 It touched me a lot. I would love to hear your opinion on my site. Please come to the site I run once and leave a comment. Thank you.
What an interesting story! I'm glad I finally found what I was looking for Kèo hay.
Many thanks for the article, I have a lot of spray lining knowledge but always learn something new. Keep up the good work and thank you again. 크레이지슬롯
That was an excellent article. You made some great points and I am grateful for for your information! Take care! 토토
You were great and everyone received so much from your experience and knowledge
Absolutely amazing, thank you for sharing your knowledge with me. 토토사이트
I'm writing on this topic these days, , but I have stopped writing because there is no reference material. Then I accidentally found your article. I can refer to a variety of materials, so I think the work I was preparing will work! Thank you for your efforts. Bong do
I've been searching for hours on this topic and finally found your post. , I have read your post and I am very impressed. We prefer your opinion and will visit this site frequently to refer to your opinion. When would you like to visit my site? soi kèo
Thank you a bunch for sharing this with all of us you actually realize what you are talking about! Bookmarked. Please also seek advice from my site =). We could have a hyperlink change contract between us 메이저놀이터
Thank you for some other informative blog. Where else could I get that type of information written in such an ideal means? I have a mission that I’m just now working on, and I have been at the look out for such information. 안전놀이터 It helped me a lot. If you have time, I hope you come to my site and share your opinions. Have a nice day.
It's great. You will certainly really feel that your writing is unbelievable even if you consider it. I enjoyed to see your writing as well as my sensations are still remaining. I wish you will certainly be impressed much like me when you see my writing. Would certainly you such as to find as well as see my article? 바카라사이트
Howdy! Do you know if they make any plugins to assist with SEO? I’m trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not seeing very good results. If you know of any please share. Cheers! 먹튀검증커뮤니티
"It’s the ideal a chance to make a number of plans for the longer term and it’s time for you to be at liberty. We have learn this publish of course, if I could..I wish to counsel you few interesting issues or advice. Perhaps you can write next articles regarding this short article.
I wish to read more things approximately it!"
야한동영상
"The sector hopes for a lot more passionate writers just like
you who are certainly not afraid to bring up the way that they believe.
Constantly follow your heart."
스포츠마사지
Hi there, just become alert to your weblog through Google, and found that it's truly informative.
출장마사지
Thanks for such a valuable post. I am waiting for your next post, I have enjoyed a lot reading this post keep it up.
바카라사이트
Such an amazing and helpful post. I really really love it.
카지노사이트
That's a really impressive new idea! casino api It touched me a lot. I would love to hear your opinion on my site. Please come to the site I run once and leave a comment. Thank you.
Hi there, I simply hopped over in your website by way of StumbleUpon. Now not one thing I’d typically learn, but I favored your emotions none the less. Thank you for making something worth reading. 메이저사이트순위
La forma más rápida de consultar tu cita SEPE, es hacer una rápida llamada al número de teléfono oficial del INEM: 900 81 24 00
Mapamundis de todo tipo para imprimir ✓ Políticos y Físicos ✓ Imágenes de mapas del mundo de gran tamaño y definición HD ✓ Encuentra tu planisferio
Si deseas aprender las denominaciones oficiales (en catalán) utiliza el juego en catalán: comarcas de catalunya. On es? Localización. Localización. Continente.
Shillong Teer Common Number — Shillong Teer Result 13-12-2021, Shillong Teer Hit Number, Morning Common Number. Are you searching Shillong Teer Result,
Get fastest updated Teer results online here. We provide Shillong Teer results, Khanapara Teer results, Juwai Teer Results, Night Teer results online fast.
I’m thinking some of my readers might find a bit of this interesting. Do you mind if I post a clip from this and link back? Thanks 먹튀검증
As I am looking at your writing, 파워볼사이트 I regret being unable to do outdoor activities due to Corona 19, and I miss my old daily life. If you also miss the daily life of those days, would you please visit my site once? My site is a site where I post about photos and daily life when I was free.
I have bookmarked your website because this site contains valuable information in it. I am really happy with articles quality and presentation. Thanks a lot for keeping great stuff. I am very much thankful for this site. Feel free to visit my website;
야설
Your work is very good and I appreciate you and hopping for some more informative posts. Thank you for sharing great information to us Feel free to visit my website; 국산야동
Great Post !! Very interesting topic will bookmark your site to check if you write more about in the future. This post is really astounding one! I was delighted to read this, very much useful. Many thanks Feel free to visit my website; 일본야동
My website is in the exact same niche as yours and my visitors would genuinely benefit from some of the information you provide here. Please let me know if this okay with you. This paragraph is genuinely a nice one it assists new net visitors, who are wishing in favor of blogging. Thanks Feel free to visit my website; 일본야동
3 Ways Bad 먹튀검증업체 Players REALLY Affect You
Your writing is perfect and complete. However, I think it will be more wonderful if your post includes additional topics that I am thinking of. I have a lot of posts on my site similar to your topic. Would you like to visit once? keonha cai
Thanks for such a fantastic blog. Where else could anyone get that kind of info written in such a perfect way? I have a presentation that I am presently writhing on, and I have been on the look out for such great information. 메이저토토
DEMOLITION HAS BEGUN!!! 메이저토토사이트추천 HOTEL BATHROOMS HER WE COME!!!
Hi! This is my first visit to your blog! We are a team of volunteers and new initiatives in the same niche. Blog gave us useful information to work. You have done an amazing job! 메이저토토사이트 Thank you very much. Can I refer to your post on my website? Your post touched me a lot and helped me a lot. If you have any questions, please visit my site and read what kind of posts I am posting. I am sure it will be interesting.
While looking for articles on these topics, I came across this article on the site here. As I read your article, I felt like an expert in this field. I have several articles on these topics posted on my site. Could you please visit my homepage? 메이저놀이터순위
Royalcasino792
Looking at this article, I miss the time when I didn't wear a mask. 카지노게임사이트 Hopefully this corona will end soon. My blog is a blog that mainly posts pictures of daily life before Corona and landscapes at that time. If you want to remember that time again, please visit us.
How to Beat the 몰디브 게임 다운로드 : Pro Gambler Martin Butterick
Appreciate your work very interesting post, Kindly share more with us! 메이저토토
Post a Comment